ПОВЫШЕНИЕ ЭФФЕКТИВНОСТИ ОБЕСПЕЧЕНИЯ ПОЖАРНОЙ БЕЗОПАСНОСТИ ОБЪЕКТОВ ДУХОВНОГО ТУРИЗМА ВО ВЬЕТНАМЕ В ПЕРИОД ФЕСТИВАЛЕЙ НАЧАЛА ГОДА
Enhancing the Effectiveness of Fire Prevention and Firefighting at Spiritual Tourism Sites in Vietnam During the Early-Year Festival Season
- 1 University of Fire Prevention and Fighting of the Ministry of Public Security of Vietnam
В статье анализируются риски пожаров на объектах духовного туризма во Вьетнаме в период проведения традиционных фестивалей в начале года, когда наблюдается высокая концентрация посетителей и интенсивная религиозная деятельность. На основе анализа особенностей функционирования религиозных объектов и практики обеспечения пожарной безопасности во Вьетнаме в исследовании выявлены основные факторы пожарного риска, включая использование благовоний, свечей и масляных ламп, сжигание ритуальной бумаги, высокую плотность посетителей, а также ограничения инфраструктуры пожарной безопасности. В статье предложены меры по повышению эффективности обеспечения пожарной безопасности на объектах духовного туризма, направленные на защиту жизни людей, сохранность имущества и культурного наследия.
This article analyzes fire risks at spiritual tourism sites in Vietnam during the early-year festival season, when large crowds gather and religious activities take place intensively. Based on an analysis of the operational characteristics of religious sites and the current practices of fire prevention and firefighting in Vietnam, the study identifies several major fire risk factors, including the burning of incense and votive paper offerings, the use of candles and oil lamps, overcrowding of pilgrims, and limitations in fire safety infrastructure. The article proposes measures to enhance fire safety management at spiritual tourism sites, thereby contributing to the protection of human life, property, and cultural heritage values.
This article analyzes fire risks at spiritual tourism sites in Vietnam during the early-year festival season, when large crowds gather and religious activities take place intensively. Based on an analysis of the operational characteristics of religious sites and the current practices of fire prevention and firefighting in Vietnam, the study identifies several major fire risk factors, including the burning of incense and votive paper offerings, the use of candles and oil lamps, overcrowding of pilgrims, and limitations in fire safety infrastructure. On that basis, the article proposes a number of measures to enhance the effectiveness of fire safety management at spiritual tourism sites, thereby contributing to the protection of human life, property, and cultural heritage values.
Keywords: fire safety, fire prevention and firefighting, spiritual tourism, religious heritage sites, festivals.
ПОВЫШЕНИЕ ЭФФЕКТИВНОСТИ ОБЕСПЕЧЕНИЯ ПОЖАРНОЙ БЕЗОПАСНОСТИ ОБЪЕКТОВ ДУХОВНОГО ТУРИЗМА ВО ВЬЕТНАМЕ В ПЕРИОД ФЕСТИВАЛЕЙ НАЧАЛА ГОДА
В статье анализируются риски пожаров на объектах духовного туризма во Вьетнаме в период проведения традиционных фестивалей в начале года, когда наблюдается высокая концентрация посетителей и интенсивная религиозная деятельность. На основе анализа особенностей функционирования религиозных объектов и практики обеспечения пожарной безопасности во Вьетнаме в исследовании выявлены основные факторы пожарного риска, включая использование благовоний, свечей и масляных ламп, сжигание ритуальной бумаги, высокую плотность посетителей, а также ограничения инфраструктуры пожарной безопасности. В статье предложены меры по повышению эффективности обеспечения пожарной безопасности на объектах духовного туризма, направленные на защиту жизни людей, сохранность имущества и культурного наследия.
Ключевые слова: пожарная безопасность, предупреждение и тушение пожаров, духовный туризм, религиозные объекты культурного наследия, фестивали.
1. Introduction
In recent years, spiritual tourism has become one of the rapidly growing forms of tourism in Vietnam, associated with a rich system of historical, religious, and belief-related heritage sites. According to statistics from cultural management authorities, Vietnam currently has approximately 8,000 traditional festivals, most of which are organized in the spring and closely associated with places of worship such as temples, pagodas, shrines, and historical-cultural sites. Several major festivals in Vietnam attract hundreds of thousands to millions of pilgrims each year, creating considerable pressure on ensuring fire safety at religious and spiritual tourism sites.
In the context of increasingly diverse and complex non-traditional security risks in Southeast Asia, safety management in spaces with large public gatherings, such as religious and cultural festivals, has received growing attention through integrated risk management approaches. This requires authorities and festival organizers to proactively identify and control potential hazards, among which fire risk at religious and spiritual tourism sites represents a significant concern.
During festival periods, religious activities such as incense burning, the burning of votive paper offerings, and the use of candles, oil lamps, and electrical lighting devices occur frequently, generating numerous potential sources of ignition and heat. At the same time, many religious buildings were constructed long ago, with structural components primarily made of wood and other combustible materials, while their interiors often contain wooden statues, altars, and cultural artifacts of high historical value. When fires occur, these factors can cause fires to spread rapidly and lead to severe damage. According to reports from the Ministry of Public Security, during the period from 2020 to 2024 several fire incidents were still recorded at religious sites and historical monuments, causing property damage and affecting cultural heritage values.
In addition, many spiritual tourism destinations also host temporary service activities during festival periods, including stalls, shops selling ritual offerings, food service areas, and parking facilities. Electrical systems supporting these activities are sometimes installed temporarily and may not be fully controlled in terms of technical safety, thereby increasing the risk of fire due to electrical short circuits or improper use of open flames.
In this context, studying fire risks and proposing measures to enhance the effectiveness of fire prevention and firefighting at spiritual tourism sites during the early-year festival season is of significant importance. Such measures not only contribute to ensuring the safety of residents and visitors but also help protect cultural and historical heritage while promoting the sustainable development of spiritual tourism in Vietnam.
2. Analysis of fire risks and the current status of fire safety assurance at spiritual tourism sites in Vietnam
Spiritual tourism sites in Vietnam, such as temples, pagodas, shrines, and historical-cultural complexes, possess distinctive characteristics in terms of architecture, religious activities, and festival organization. These characteristics make such locations potentially vulnerable to fire hazards, particularly during the early-year festival season when large numbers of visitors gather within a short period of time. Therefore, analyzing both fire risk factors and the current status of fire safety assurance at these sites is essential for proposing appropriate preventive measures.
First, common fire risks arise from religious practices involving the direct use of open flames. In many religious rituals, activities such as burning incense, lighting candles and oil lamps, and burning votive paper offerings are frequently performed. During festival periods, the number of visitors participating in these rituals increases significantly, and many people simultaneously burn incense in worship areas. If not properly managed, embers or heat generated from these open flames may ignite combustible materials such as decorative paper, fabric curtains, or ritual items.
Second, the architectural characteristics of religious buildings and historical monuments also increase fire risk. Many of these structures were built long ago and are primarily constructed from wood and other traditional combustible materials, particularly in temple and pagoda complexes with traditional wooden architecture. Inside worship spaces, numerous wooden statues, horizontal lacquered boards and parallel inscriptions, ritual objects, and decorative materials made of fabric or paper are often present. In the event of a fire, these materials can act as a significant fuel source, facilitating rapid fire spread.
Liao, Zhuo and Tao (2024) demonstrate that historic areas with dense spatial layouts and extensive use of combustible materials, particularly wooden buildings, are highly vulnerable to rapid fire spread and large-scale fire losses, as the short distance between buildings and the accumulation of combustible fuel significantly facilitate fire propagation.
In addition, large crowd gatherings during festival seasons significantly increase fire risk levels. At many major spiritual tourism destinations, the number of pilgrims may increase several times compared to normal days. High population density within limited spaces not only increases the likelihood of fire ignition but also complicates evacuation procedures and the deployment of firefighting forces in emergency situations.
Furthermore, auxiliary service activities that support festival events also pose considerable fire risks. During festival periods, many temporary stalls, ritual offering shops, food service areas, and vehicle parking zones appear around heritage sites. Electrical systems used for these activities are sometimes installed temporarily and may lack adequate technical safety control, thereby increasing the risk of fire due to electrical short circuits or overloading.
In recent years, fire safety assurance at spiritual tourism sites has received increasing attention from authorities and heritage management boards, particularly during major festivals. Many localities have conducted fire safety inspections prior to festival seasons, issued guidelines on the arrangement of incense-burning and votive paper burning areas, equipped initial firefighting facilities, and organized on-site response forces at heritage locations.
However, practical experience shows that fire safety management at these types of facilities still faces several limitations. Fire safety conditions vary considerably among spiritual tourism sites; at many small-scale religious locations, the provision of firefighting equipment, organization of on-site firefighting forces, and regular safety inspections remain limited. In some cases, the management of open flames in religious activities is not strictly controlled, and the practice of burning excessive incense or votive paper outside designated areas still occurs. According to UNESCO (Marrion, 2024), many cultural heritage sites and historic structures worldwide face increasing fire risks, particularly at locations with wooden architecture and insufficient fire protection systems.
Moreover, many spiritual tourism sites are located within heritage complexes with ancient architectural layouts or in areas with complex terrain, which may limit access for professional firefighting vehicles. Fire alarm systems and early fire detection solutions have not been sufficiently installed at many heritage sites due to architectural preservation requirements and financial constraints. Some fire safety standards for religious buildings, such as the Russian fire safety code SP 258, stipulate that worship spaces accommodating large numbers of people must provide at least two evacuation exits and adequate exit widths to ensure safe evacuation in the event of a fire.
For large public gatherings such as early-year festivals, multi-hazard risk assessment approaches can be informed by international tools such as the Generic All-Hazards Risk Assessment Tool developed by the World Health Organization (WHO). Although this tool is not specifically designed for fire safety, it enables the identification of multiple hazards and the evaluation of their potential impacts, thereby supporting decision-makers in selecting appropriate risk mitigation measures for specific festival sites.
From the above analysis, it can be seen that spiritual tourism sites during the early-year festival season represent a category of facilities with relatively high fire risk due to the combined effects of traditional architectural characteristics, religious activities involving open flames, and the concentration of large crowds within a short period of time. These conditions highlight the need for appropriate management and technical solutions to enhance fire safety assurance at spiritual tourism destinations.
3. Measures to enhance the effectiveness of fire prevention and firefighting at spiritual tourism sites
Based on the analysis of fire risk factors at spiritual tourism sites during the early-year festival season, improving the effectiveness of fire prevention and firefighting should be implemented comprehensively through solutions related to management organization, technical measures, and public awareness raising.
First, it is necessary to strengthen management and fire safety inspections at spiritual tourism sites before and during the festival season. Relevant authorities should coordinate with local governments and heritage management boards to conduct regular inspections of fire safety conditions, particularly regarding electrical systems, incense-burning areas, votive paper burning areas, and service facilities surrounding heritage sites. The timely identification and remediation of potential fire hazards are important measures to prevent fire and explosion incidents during festival periods.
Second, areas involving the use of open flames in religious activities should be carefully planned and strictly managed. At places of worship, designated areas for incense burning and votive paper burning should be arranged separately and maintain safe distances from buildings and combustible materials. In addition, appropriate measures should be introduced to control the number of incense sticks burned in each worship area in order to avoid excessive burning that may increase fire risks.
Third, the provision of on-site fire protection equipment at spiritual tourism sites should be strengthened. These locations should be equipped with adequate initial firefighting facilities such as portable fire extinguishers, fire alarm systems, and early fire detection devices. At the same time, reliable water sources for firefighting should be ensured, along with convenient access routes for professional firefighting vehicles in the event of an emergency.
Fourth, the capacity of on-site firefighting forces should be improved through regular training and the development of fire and rescue response plans tailored to the specific characteristics of each spiritual tourism site. Heritage management staff and festival service personnel should be equipped with basic knowledge and skills for handling initial fire incidents, and regular drills should be conducted to enhance coordination during emergencies.
Fifth, efforts should be strengthened to raise awareness among local residents and visitors regarding fire safety. Spiritual tourism sites should install warning signs and fire safety instructions in worship areas and public spaces. Disseminating fire safety regulations through loudspeaker systems, information boards, and other communication channels can significantly improve visitors’ awareness and responsibility in preventing fire incidents.
In addition to these management and organizational measures, long-term efforts should focus on the application of digital technologies in heritage protection and fire safety management. Technologies such as digital models of heritage structures, temperature monitoring sensors, early fire detection cameras, and digital data management platforms can support real-time monitoring of building conditions. These technologies can enhance early detection capabilities and fire prevention for wooden architectural structures and valuable cultural artifacts located at spiritual tourism sites.
The coordinated implementation of these measures will contribute to reducing fire risks and improving the effectiveness of fire prevention and firefighting at spiritual tourism sites during the early-year festival season. Ultimately, this will help ensure the safety of residents and visitors while protecting the cultural and historical values of heritage sites.
4. Conclusion
Spiritual tourism sites in Vietnam represent locations of significant cultural, historical, and religious value. At the same time, they are places where large numbers of people gather during early-year festivals. The rapid increase in the number of visitors, together with the specific characteristics of religious practices such as incense burning, the burning of votive paper offerings, and the use of open flames in religious rituals, has considerably increased fire risks at these locations. In addition, many religious buildings and historical monuments are constructed from combustible materials, while technical infrastructure and access conditions for firefighting vehicles remain limited in some areas, which may lead to more severe consequences in the event of a fire.
The analysis indicates that fire risks at spiritual tourism sites during the early-year festival season arise from multiple factors, including architectural characteristics, religious activities involving open flames, high crowd density, and auxiliary service activities. Therefore, ensuring fire safety at these locations requires comprehensive solutions that combine state management measures, effective festival organization, and improved community awareness.
The solutions proposed in this study include strengthening fire safety inspection and supervision; planning and strictly controlling areas where open flames are used in religious activities; enhancing the provision of initial firefighting equipment and improving the capacity of on-site firefighting forces; and promoting communication and public education on fire safety for both residents and visitors.
The effective implementation of these measures will not only contribute to reducing fire risks and ensuring the safety of residents and visitors during the early-year festival season, but also play an important role in protecting cultural and historical heritage and promoting the sustainable development of spiritual tourism in Vietnam.
References
1. National Assembly of Vietnam (2024). Law on Fire Prevention, Firefighting and Rescue. Hanoi.
2. Government of Vietnam (2025). Decree No. 105/2025/ND-CP dated 15 May 2025 on Detailed Provisions for the Implementation of the Law on Fire Prevention, Firefighting and Rescue Operations. Hanoi.
3. Ministry of Emergency Situations of the Russian Federation (2016). SP 258.1311500.2016. Buildings for Religious Use. Fire Safety Requirements. – Moscow: VNIIPO EMERCOM of Russia.
4. Marrion C. (2024). Fire Risk Management Guide: Protecting Cultural and Natural Heritage from Fire. – Paris: UNESCO.
5. Liao D., Zhuo X., Tao J. (2024). A Dynamic Fire Risk Assessment Method for Compact Historic Villages Based on the Improved FRAME // International Journal of Disaster Risk Reduction. – Vol. 114. – Art. 104935. – DOI: 10.1016/j.ijdrr.2024.104935.