Анализ эффективности страхования от пожаров во Вьетнаме на основе регрессионной модели
Analysis of the effectiveness of fire insurance in Vietnam based on the regression model
- 1 Институт пожарной безопасности МОБ Вьетнама
Проведена оценка факторов, влияющих на деятельность по страхованию от пожаров во Вьетнаме. Для анализа использовалась панельная регрессионная модель на основе данных пяти страховых компаний. Результаты исследования подтверждают, что такие факторы, как длительность деятельности, размер активов, финансовый рычаг и коэффициент убытков, оказывают существенное влияние на бизнес страхования от пожаров во Вьетнаме.
An assessment of the factors influencing fire insurance activity in Vietnam was conducted. A panel regression model based on data from five insurance companies was used for the analysis. The study's results confirm that factors such as duration of operation, asset size, financial leverage, and loss ratio have a significant impact on fire insurance performance in Vietnam.
This study employs a quantitative research methodology to investigate the factors affecting the fire and explosion insurance business of non-life insurance companies in Vietnam. The research model is built upon Resource-Based Theory and Stakeholder Theory [1, 2].
The dependent variable for assessing business performance is the proportion of fire and explosion insurance within the product portfolio of non-life insurers. This is measured by the net revenue from fire and explosion insurance activities as reported in audited financial statements.
- Independent Variables and Hypotheses
The study identifies the following independent variables as potential factors influencing the fire and explosion insurance business:
1. Interest rate (INT)
The interest rate is a key macroeconomic factor that influences both insurance companies and their clients. For insurers, interest rates directly affect investment strategies and financial structures. Higher interest rates typically increase returns on fixed-income instruments such as bonds and deposits, while lower interest rates may reduce investment income and encourage insurers to pursue riskier asset classes. Interest rates also impact the cost of capital, thereby shaping insurers’ financial structure [1, 3, 4].
For corporate clients, the effect of interest rates on the demand for fire and explosion insurance is indirect. This type of insurance is primarily associated with the value of physical assets and is often subject to legal requirements.
Ha0: Interest rate has a significant effect on the fire and explosion insurance business of non-life insurance companies.
Ha1: Interest rate has no significant effect on the fire and explosion insurance business of non-life insurance companies.
2. Number of years in operation (AGE)
The number of years in operation reflects an insurer’s accumulation of organizational resources, which aligns with the perspective of the Resource-Based Theory (Barney, 1991). According to RBT, intangible resources such as reputation, brand value, and long-term customer relationships can serve as a source of sustained competitive advantage when they are valuable, rare, inimitable, and well-organized. Insurers with longer operating histories are more likely to possess these intangible assets, thereby strengthening their market credibility and customer trust. These advantages contribute to improved business performance across different insurance lines, including fire and explosion insurance [1, 3, 4].
Hb0: The number of years in operation has a significant effect on the fire and explosion insurance business of non-life insurance companies.
Hb1: The number of years in operation has no significant effect on the fire and explosion insurance business of non-life insurance companies.
3. Company size (SIZE)
Company size is an important indicator of organizational resources. Larger firms often have greater capacity to utilize both short-term and long-term assets to gain competitive advantages. They are more capable of investing in product development, improving human resources, and expanding into new markets, which can strengthen overall competitiveness. However, because assets are financed through a mix of debt and equity, a heavy dependence on debt may increase interest expenses and raise the risk of financial distress in the long run. In the scope of this study, company size is measured by the natural logarithm of total assets to minimize the influence of outliers [1, 3, 4].
Hypothesis Hc0: Company size has a significant effect on the business performance of fire and explosion insurance in non-life insurance companies.
Hypothesis Hc1: Company size has no significant effect on the business performance of fire and explosion insurance in non-life insurance companies.
4. Financial Leverage (LEV)
Financial leverage reflects the extent to which a company relies on debt in its capital structure. By employing financial leverage, firms can utilize external capital to support business expansion. However, a high debt ratio may increase financial risk through greater interest expenses and heightened solvency pressure. As a result, companies may adopt a more cautious approach when developing high-risk products such as insurance.
Compared with other types of insurance, fire and explosion insurance is directly associated with the protection of high-value physical assets such as buildings, factories, machinery, and inventories. The level of risk in this line of insurance depends heavily on factors such as the value and characteristics of the insured property, compliance with fire safety standards, and the effectiveness of preventive measures. Consequently, fire and explosion insurance tends to involve highpotential losses and requires rigorous risk assessment and management [1, 3, 4].
Hd0: Financial leverage has a significant effect on the fire and explosion insurance business of non-life insurance companies.
Hd1: Financial leverage has no significant effect on the fire and explosion insurance business of non-life insurance companies.
5. Loss ratio (LOSS)
The loss ratio reflects the actual risk an insurance company bears on its issued issurance contract. A high loss ratio can negatively or positively impact a company's profitability, depending on its risk management. Therefore, the ability to effectively control and manage the loss ratio is a key factor for sustainable development in the fire and explosion insurance sector.
He0: Loss ratio has a significant effect on the fire and explosion insurance business of non-life insurance companies.
He1: Loss ratio has no significant effect on the fire and explosion insurance business of non-life insurance companies.
Data collection and analysis methods
This study uses secondary data collected from the audited financial statements of six non-life insurance companies in Vietnam from 2017 to 2023. Interest rate data is extracted from the World Bank database.
To ensure the reliability of the model, the study performs various diagnostic tests, including heteroskedasticity, serial correlation, and multicollinearity tests, using STATA 17 software.
- Research Results
Given that the research model is based on panel data (combining cross-sectional and time-series data), a simple Ordinary Least Squares (OLS) model is often insufficient for complex analysis. Therefore, the author utilizes both the Random Effects Model (REM) and the Fixed Effects Model (FEM). A Hausman test is then conducted to determine the most appropriate model. Table 1 presents the regression results for both the Random Effects and Fixed Effects models [5].
Table 1 - Random Effect Model and Fixed Effect Model regression
REM | FEM | |||
Coefficient | P-value | Coefficient | P-value | |
AGE | 0.0131565 | 0.000*** | 0.0147421 | 0.02** |
INT | -0.0025943 | 0.750 | 0.0026585 | 0.755 |
SIZE | -0.0466285 | 0.020** | -0.1176411 | 0.001*** |
LEV | -0.1273303 | 0.199 | 0.21135363 | 0.0530* |
LOSS | 0.0773689 | 0.310 | 0.2261367 | 0.009*** |
Hausman test | 0.3184 | F-test | 0.0000*** | |
The results of the F-test indicate that the FEM model is statistically significant and performs better than the Pooled OLS model. However, the Hausman test, with a P-value greater than 5%, suggests no statistically significant difference between the REM and FEM estimators, thereby supporting the use of the REM model. Consequently, the REM model is selected for further diagnostic testing. Table 2 presents the results of the heteroskedasticity test for the REM model.
Table 2 - Heteroskedasticity test result
Test: Var(u)=0 | |
Chibar2(01) | 17.87 |
Prob>Chibar2 | 0.0000*** |
The p-value of the heteroskedasticity test is significant at the 1% level, indicating that the REM model suffers from heteroskedasticity. In the presence of heteroskedasticity, the estimators remain unbiased but are no longer efficient, and the estimated standard errors become biased.
Table 3 - Wooldridge test result
Wooldridge test for autocorrelation in panel data | |
H0 | No first-order autocorrelation |
F(1,5) | 11.914 |
Prob>F | 0.0182** |
The p-value of the Wooldridge test is significant at the 5% level, suggesting the presence of first-order serial correlation in the model. Based on the results in Table 4, the variance inflation factor (VIF) of the independent variables and the average VIF of the model are all below 5. This indicates that multicollinearity is not a problem in the model.
Table 4 - Multicollinearity test - Variance Inflation Factor
Variable | VIF | 1/VIF |
INT | 2.12 | 0.472683 |
AGE | 1.88 | 0.531236 |
LOSS | 1.84 | 0.543975 |
SIZE | 1.83 | 0.546887 |
LEV | 1.48 | 0.675846 |
Mean VIF | 1.53 |
Given these diagnostic results, the author applies the feasible generalized least squares (FGLS) estimation method to address both serial correlation and heteroskedasticity. The regression results using FGLS are summarized in Table 5.
Table 5 - FGLS regression result
FIRE | Coefficient | P-value |
AGE | 0.0142838 | 0.000*** |
INT | -0.0084423 | 0.211 |
SIZE | -0.0309038 | 0.043** |
LEV | -0.2063647 | 0.026** |
LOSS | 0.1616784 | 0.022** |
The FGLS method has corrected the problems of heteroskedasticity and serial correlation in the research model. The regression results in Table 5 show that years in operation (AGE), firm size (SIZE), financial leverage (LEV), and loss ratio (LOSS) significantly affect the fire and explosion insurance business of non-life insurance companies.
AGE: Years in operation have a positive relationship with the fire and explosion insurance business at the 1% significance level. The longer an insurer has been in operation, the more favorable its business performance tends to be.
SIZE: Firm size has a negative relationship with the fire and explosion insurance business at the 5% significance level. As insurers expand their total assets, their fire and explosion insurance business tends to contract.
LEV: Financial leverage has a negative relationship with the fire and explosion insurance business at the 5% significance level. When the debt ratio in the capital structure increases, insurers are more likely to restrict their involvement in high-risk businesses such as fire and explosion insurance.
LOSS: The results indicate that LOSS has a positive and statistically significant impact on the fire and explosion insurance business. This can be explained in two main ways. First, a higher loss ratio may lead insurers to adjust premiums upward. Since fire and explosion insurance is largely mandatory under legal regulations, such premium increases do not necessarily reduce demand, thereby allowing insurers to sustain business performance. Second, reinsurance plays a stabilizing role: through loss-sharing mechanisms, insurers can transfer part of their risk exposure to reinsurers, which helps them maintain underwriting capacity and continue offering fire and explosion insurance despite higher loss ratios.
- Discussion
The findings of this study provide several important insights into the dynamics of the fire and explosion insurance business among non-life insurance companies in Vietnam. The regression results demonstrate that internal firm characteristics such as years in operation, company size, financial leverage, and loss ratio play a critical role in determining performance, while macroeconomic factors like interest rates appear to have limited influence [2].
First, the positive impact of years in operation (AGE) highlights the importance of accumulated experience, reputation, and established customer networks. The results suggest that longevity and accumulated knowledge remain significant competitive advantages in this business line.
Second, the negative relationship between company size (SIZE) and the fire and explosion insurance business reflects a paradox. While larger firms typically have stronger resource bases, the results indicate that as total assets increase, fire and explosion insurance activities tend to contract.
Third, financial leverage (LEV) is found to have a negative effect on the business. Highly leveraged firms appear more risk-averse, limiting their exposure to fire and explosion insurance, which demands significant capital reserves to cover potential large-scale claims. This is consistent with Stakeholder Theory (Freeman, 1984), as insurers must balance the interests of creditors and regulators by maintaining solvency and stability [4].
Fourth, the positive and significant impact of the loss ratio (LOSS) reveals an interesting dynamic. This result highlights the dual role of risk: while high claims ratios may signal vulnerabilities, they can also drive premium adjustments and strengthen market stability through risk-sharing arrangements.
Finally, the absence of a significant effect of interest rates (INT) suggests that macroeconomic fluctuations in capital costs have little direct impact on fire and explosion insurance. Unlike investment-driven products, this line of business is primarily determined by regulatory requirements and the tangible need to protect high-value assets. Thus, while interest rates affect insurers’ investment income, they do not significantly alter demand or performance in compulsory fire and explosion insurance.
Overall, these findings reinforce the notion that firm-specific resources and management decisions are more influential than macroeconomic variables in shaping the performance of fire and explosion insurance in Vietnam. From a practical perspective, insurers should focus on leveraging experience, optimizing risk management, and maintaining financial prudence to enhance competitiveness in this critical line of business.
Literature
- Barney, J. (1991). Firm resources and sustained competitive advantage. Journal of Management, 17(1), 99–120.
- Freeman, R. E. (1984). Strategic Management: A Stakeholder Approach. Pitman Publishing.
- Penrose, E. T. (1959). The Theory of the Growth of the Firm. Oxford University Press.
- Wernerfelt, B. (1984). A resource‐based view of the firm. Strategic Management Journal, 5(2), 171–180.
- National Assembly. (2024). Law on Fire Prevention and Fighting No. 55/2024/QH15. Office of the National Assembly.