34-я международная научно-техническая конференция "Системы безопасности – 2025"·Нормативно-правовые, образовательные, социальные и психологические проблемы безопасностиУДК 614.849

Прогнозирование пожарных рисков и управленческие решения для складов и производственных объектов в Ханое в контексте нетрадиционной безопасности

Fire risk prediction and management solutions for warehouses and industrial facilities in Hanoi in the context of non-traditional security

Ле Вьет Хай1,Nguyen Van Tuan2
  1. 1 University of Fire Prevention and Fighting of the Minis-try of Public Security of Vietnam
  2. 2 Vietnam National University, Hanoi – School of Business and Management
16 октября 2025 2 просмотров 14 мин чтения
Аннотация

В статье анализируются пожарные риски на складах и производственных объектах Ханоя с позиции нетрадиционной безопасности. На основе интегрированной аналитической схемы, включающей правовые, организационные, технические и социальные факторы, выявлены ключевые уязвимости в существующей системе управления рисками. Определены ожидаемые тенденции развития пожарных рисков на период 2025–2030 годов, связанные с быстрым ростом промышленности, климатическими условиями и ограниченной городской инфраструктурой безопасности. Проанализирован международный опыт и предложены управленческие решения, адаптированные к условиям Ханоя, с акцентом на правовые реформы, цифровой мониторинг рисков, технологическую модернизацию и активизацию участия сообщества. Результаты исследования способствуют повышению готовности и снижению системных пожарных рисков в рамках концепции нетрадиционной безопасности.

#пожарный риск#склады и производственные объекты#нетрадиционная безопасность#управление рисками#Ханой
Abstract

This paper analyzes fire risks in warehouses and factories in Hanoi from the perspective of non-traditional security. Using a synthesized framework that integrates key legal, organizational, technical and social factors, the study identifies major vulnerabilities in current risk governance. Expected fire risk trends for the period 2025–2030 are outlined, reflecting the impact of rapid industrial growth, climate conditions and limited urban safety infrastructure. The paper reviews relevant international models and proposes governance solutions adapted to Hanoi, with emphasis on legal reforms, digital risk monitoring, technological upgrading and strengthened community participation. The findings contribute to improving long-term preparedness and reducing systemic fire risks under the non-traditional security framework.

#fire risk#warehouses and factories#non-traditional security#risk governance#Hanoi
Полный текст2540 слов

FORECASTING FIRE RISKS AND GOVERNANCE SOLUTIONS FOR WAREHOUSES AND FACTORIES IN HANOI UNDER THE FRAMEWORK OF NON-TRADITIONAL SECURITY

This paper analyzes fire risks in warehouses and factories in Hanoi from the perspective of non-traditional security. Using a synthesized framework that integrates key legal, organizational, technical and social factors, the study identifies major vulnerabilities in current risk governance. Expected fire risk trends for the period 2025–2030 are outlined, reflecting the impact of rapid industrial growth, climate conditions and limited urban safety infrastructure. The paper reviews relevant international models and proposes governance solutions adapted to Hanoi, with emphasis on legal reforms, digital risk monitoring, technological upgrading and strengthened community participation. The findings contribute to improving long-term preparedness and reducing systemic fire risks under the non-traditional security framework.

Keywords: fire risk; warehouses and factories; non-traditional security; risk governance; Hanoi.

ПРОГНОЗИРОВАНИЕ ПОЖАРНЫХ РИСКОВ И УПРАВЛЕНЧЕСКИЕ РЕШЕНИЯ ДЛЯ СКЛАДОВ И ПРОИЗВОДСТВЕННЫХ ОБЪЕКТОВ В ХАНОЕ В КОНТЕКСТЕ НЕТРАДИЦИОННОЙ БЕЗОПАСНОСТИ

В статье анализируются пожарные риски на складах и производственных объектах Ханоя с позиции нетрадиционной безопасности. На основе интегрированной аналитической схемы, включающей правовые, организационные, технические и социальные факторы, выявлены ключевые уязвимости в существующей системе управления рисками. Определены ожидаемые тенденции развития пожарных рисков на период 2025–2030 годов, связанные с быстрым ростом промышленности, климатическими условиями и ограниченной городской инфраструктурой безопасности. Проанализирован международный опыт и предложены управленческие решения, адаптированные к условиям Ханоя, с акцентом на правовые реформы, цифровой мониторинг рисков, технологическую модернизацию и активизацию участия сообщества. Результаты исследования способствуют повышению готовности и снижению системных пожарных рисков в рамках концепции нетрадиционной безопасности.

Ключевые слова: пожарный риск; склады и производственные объекты; нетрадиционная безопасность; управление рисками; Ханой.

1. Introduction

Hanoi has experienced a steady increase in fires involving warehouses and factories, particularly in areas where industrial facilities are located near dense residential zones. These incidents have caused significant human and economic losses, disrupted local supply chains and placed pressure on emergency response forces [1]. In a rapidly urbanizing and industrializing environment, fire risks are no longer confined to technical failures alone but interact with broader social, environmental and economic vulnerabilities.

This wider perspective aligns with the concept of non-traditional security, in which fire incidents are viewed as threats that undermine human well-being, economic stability and community resilience. From this standpoint, improving fire safety requires not only compliance with technical regulations but also effective governance mechanisms capable of addressing complex risk factors [2]. However, existing research and policy discussions in Vietnam rarely approach industrial fire risks through this multidimensional security lens.

The scarcity of integrated risk assessments makes it difficult for local authorities and enterprises to anticipate emerging hazards or design prevention strategies suited to Hanoi’s evolving industrial landscape. To address this gap, this paper examines fire risks in warehouses and factories under the non-traditional security framework, identifies major governance challenges and proposes structured solutions adapted to Hanoi’s conditions. By adopting this approach, the study aims to contribute a more comprehensive and forward-looking perspective to fire risk management in the capital.

2. Theoretical and analytical framework

2.1. Non-traditional security perspective

Non-traditional security provides a useful lens for analyzing fire risks in industrial zones, as it highlights how threats arise not only from technical failures but also from social behavior, institutional capacity, environmental conditions and economic pressures. Under this approach, large-scale fires are considered security challenges that destabilize livelihoods, disrupt production networks, generate environmental harm and weaken public trust in local governance. For Hanoi, where industrial growth intersects with dense urbanization, applying this perspective allows for a more comprehensive understanding of systemic vulnerabilities across the entire chain of prevention, response and recovery.

2.2. Risk governance model

Risk governance emphasizes coordinated actions between the state, enterprises and communities. In this paper, the governance framework integrates four core dimensions: legal regulations, organizational structure, technical capacity and social engagement [3]. These dimensions collectively determine the effectiveness of prevention, inspection, incident mitigation and post-incident recovery.

To support analysis, the paper employs a simplified version of the MNS = 3S – 3C approach. The three “S” components represent sources of risk (structure, system, society), while the three “C” components reflect governance capacity (control, coordination, communication). Although presented briefly here, the model helps connect observed vulnerabilities with corresponding governance functions.

2.3. Key risk factors

Fire risks in warehouses and factories in Hanoi are influenced by a combination of legal, organizational, technical and social factors [3].

From a legal standpoint, overlapping or outdated standards may limit the enforcement of safety responsibilities for facility owners and operators. Organizational factors include insufficient inspection frequency, gaps in coordination among authorities and limited preparedness by enterprises. Technical risks arise from aging infrastructure, inadequate maintenance, combustible materials and limited early-warning technologies. Social risks relate to worker behavior, informal labor practices, low fire-safety awareness and the close proximity of industrial sites to residential areas.

Together, these elements form a complex risk landscape that requires integrated and forward-looking governance solutions [3].

3. Current fire risks and forecasting trends in Hanoi

3.1. Current fire risk assessment

Fire risks in warehouses and factories in Hanoi are shaped by intertwined economic, human, environmental and social vulnerabilities [1].

From an economic perspective, fires can disrupt supply chains, halt production and cause considerable financial losses for enterprises located in both industrial zones and mixed-use urban areas. Many businesses operate with limited contingency resources, making them highly sensitive to disruptions [1].

Human-related risks stem from inadequate safety awareness, limited training and unsafe work practices. A significant share of warehouse and factory workers are temporary or informal laborers who may not receive sufficient instruction on fire prevention or emergency response procedures. This increases the likelihood of human error during high-risk operations such as welding, chemical handling or equipment maintenance.

Environmental risks are associated with extreme heat, seasonal drought and the presence of flammable materials. Poor ventilation, aging electrical systems and inadequate management of hazardous substances can accelerate fire spread and intensify its consequences. In densely built industrial clusters, the proximity of facilities may contribute to escalation from isolated incidents to large-scale events.

Social risks emerge from the close integration of industrial facilities with surrounding residential communities. Encroachment, informal construction and insufficient buffer zones create conditions in which a fire at an enterprise may quickly affect nearby households. Moreover, limited community awareness and uneven cooperation with authorities can impede early detection and timely evacuation [1].

3.2. Forecasting risk trends for the period 2025–2030

Looking ahead to 2025–2030, several trends indicate that fire risks in Hanoi’s warehouses and factories may intensify if not addressed with coordinated governance measures. Rapid industrial expansion, particularly the growth of logistics hubs and small production facilities within urban districts, will increase the density of high-risk structures. Climate change is expected to raise temperatures and prolong dry periods, making electrical overloads and heat-related ignition sources more likely.

Urban development patterns also suggest that mixed-use areas, where factories, warehouses and residences coexist in close proximity, will continue to expand. Such arrangements heighten the potential for large-scale damage and complicate emergency response operations. At the same time, digital transformation in safety management remains uneven. Many enterprises lack early-warning systems, automated monitoring tools or standardized fire risk assessments. This creates gaps that may widen as technological demands grow.

These trends underscore the need for a forward-looking approach that integrates legal reforms, institutional strengthening and technological upgrading to reduce systemic vulnerabilities and enhance overall fire resilience [3].

4. International experience and lessons for Hanoi

4.1. International reference models

Several countries have developed risk governance systems that offer useful insights for improving fire safety in Hanoi’s warehouses and factories.

The European Union applies a risk-based regulatory framework under the Seveso III Directive, which requires industrial facilities to identify major hazards, map risk zones and disclose essential safety information to authorities and the public. The system emphasizes transparency and joint responsibility between enterprises and regulators, enabling early detection of critical weaknesses and timely corrective actions [4].

In the United Kingdom, fire safety management is grounded in the principle of the Responsible Person, who must conduct Fire Risk Assessments, maintain protection systems and ensure that workers understand emergency procedures. The UK model highlights accountability and continuous improvement, reducing reliance on inspections alone and encouraging self-regulation supported by periodic verification [5].

Singapore adopts a technology-oriented approach with risk-based licensing, digital inspection tools and strict enforcement mechanisms for industrial operators. Automated monitoring systems, integrated databases and building-level digital records enable authorities to detect violations quickly, analyze emerging patterns and streamline fire safety management across industrial estates.

4.2. Lessons for Hanoi

These international examples suggest several directions relevant to Hanoi.

First, risk transparency should be strengthened by requiring enterprises to conduct standardized risk assessments and share critical information with regulators and local communities. Second, clearly defined responsibility for fire safety management can enhance accountability, especially in small and medium-sized facilities. Third, expanding the use of digital tools such as early-warning systems, inspection platforms and centralized databases can help authorities monitor compliance more effectively. Finally, coordinated engagement between industrial operators, residents and local government can strengthen resilience in mixed-use urban environments.

These lessons provide a foundation for designing governance solutions tailored to the specific context and capacity of Hanoi.

5. Governance solutions for Hanoi under the non-traditional security framework

5.1. Legal and policy solutions

Strengthening the legal basis for fire safety in warehouses and factories is essential for reducing systemic risks. Regulations should clearly define the responsibilities of facility owners and operators, standardize fire risk assessment procedures and require the disclosure of essential safety information. Updating technical standards in line with modern industrial practices and clarifying enforcement mechanisms can help reduce inconsistencies in compliance [2]. Policy frameworks should also encourage enterprises to adopt digital safety tools and invest in preventive measures rather than relying solely on post-incident responses.

5.2. Organizational and managerial solutions

Effective risk governance requires coordinated institutional arrangements. Local authorities should enhance inspection frequency, improve inter-agency communication and ensure timely follow-up of identified violations. Enterprises need to establish internal fire safety teams capable of conducting routine inspections and maintaining safety equipment. Training programs for managers and workers should be standardized and regularly updated. Furthermore, emergency plans must be realistic, scenario-based and practiced through drills involving both employees and nearby residents.

5.3. Technology and infrastructure solutions

Upgrading safety infrastructure and adopting advanced technologies can significantly improve early detection and incident mitigation. Installing automated fire detection systems, thermal sensors and surveillance cameras in warehouses and factories can enhance monitoring capacity. Developing digital risk maps and integrating facilities into a centralized data platform will enable authorities to track risk levels and identify emerging hotspots. Improving access roads, water supply points and firefighting equipment in industrial zones is also critical for supporting rapid response efforts.

5.4. Community and social engagement

Community participation is a vital component within the non-traditional security approach. Enhancing fire safety awareness among workers, residents and local businesses can reduce risky behaviors and improve early detection. Collaboration between enterprises and community-based fire safety groups can facilitate information sharing and joint preparedness efforts. Reporting systems for near-miss incidents should be promoted to help identify early warning signs and prevent escalation. Strengthening trust and cooperation between communities and authorities will contribute to a more resilient urban safety environment.

5.5. Integrating 3S – 3C into governance practice

The simplified 3S – 3C model can help link identified vulnerabilities to targeted governance functions. Structural, system-related and social risks (3S) require corresponding measures in control, coordination and communication (3C). This means enhancing regulatory control for structural risks, improving institutional coordination for system-related issues and prioritizing community-based communication for social risks. Integrating this model into planning and decision-making can support a more holistic and adaptive governance approach [3].

6. Conclusion

Fire risks in warehouses and factories in Hanoi present a complex and evolving challenge that extends beyond traditional technical concerns. When examined through the lens of non-traditional security, these risks reveal multidimensional impacts on human safety, economic stability, environmental protection and social resilience. The assessment conducted in this paper shows that current vulnerabilities stem from gaps in legal enforcement, organizational coordination, infrastructure conditions and community awareness.

International experience demonstrates that risk transparency, clearly assigned responsibility, technological integration and community-oriented approaches are central to effective fire safety governance. For Hanoi, adopting these principles requires reforms in regulatory frameworks, improved inspection systems, investment in modern monitoring technologies and stronger engagement between enterprises, local authorities and surrounding communities.

The proposed governance solutions, supported by the simplified 3S – 3C model, provide a foundation for reducing systemic vulnerabilities and improving long-term preparedness. By strengthening risk governance at both institutional and community levels, Hanoi can enhance the resilience of its industrial zones and reduce the likelihood and impact of future fire incidents.

References

1. Hanoi Police Department – PC07. (2020–2025). Annual Fire Prevention and Fighting Reports and Thematic Reports on Industrial Fire Safety. Hanoi.

2. National Assembly of Vietnam. (2024). Law on Fire Prevention, Fighting, and Rescue. Hanoi.

3. International Organization for Standardization (ISO). (2018). ISO 31000:2018 – Risk Management: Guidelines. Geneva.

4. European Parliament and Council of the European Union. (2012). Directive 2012/18/EU (Seveso III) on the Control of Major-Accident Hazards Involving Dangerous Substances.

5. Government of the United Kingdom. (2005). Regulatory Reform (Fire Safety) Order 2005. London.

Есть что обсудить?
Оставьте комментарий — автор и читатели увидят его в обсуждении.