Демонтаж морских буровых установок: проблемы обеспечения пожарной безопасности и выводы по инциденту на площадке "Сонг Док"
Offshore drilling rig dismantling: fire safety challenges and lessons learned from the Song Doc incident
- 1 University of Fire Prevention and Fighting of the Ministry of Public Security of Vietnam
Рассматриваются основные проблемы в области пожарной безопасности и аварийно-спасательных мероприятий при выводе из эксплуатации морских нефтегазовых платформ на примере пожара на площадке "Сонг Док", произошедшего 21 мая 2025 года. Анализ указывает на недостатки в организации, надзоре и подготовке персонала. Предлагается комплекс мер по совершенствованию нормативной базы, укреплению технической готовности и повышению взаимодействия между ответственными структурами.
This paper examines the key challenges in fire safety and emergency rescue operations during the decommissioning of offshore oil and gas platforms, using the example of the fire at the Song Doc site that occurred on May 21, 2025. The analysis identifies deficiencies in organization, supervision, and personnel training. A set of measures is proposed to improve the regulatory framework, strengthen technical readiness, and enhance cooperation between responsible agencies.
OFFSHORE RIG DECOMMISSIONING FIRE SAFETY CHALLENGES AND INSIGHTS FROM THE SONG DOC INCIDENT
This paper examines key challenges in fire safety and rescue during the decommissioning of offshore oil platforms, using the Song Doc platform fire on May 21, 2025 as a reference case. It identifies specific risks related to residual hazards, work coordination and limited monitoring capacity. The analysis highlights weaknesses in organization, supervision and personnel readiness. A set of measures is proposed to improve the legal framework, strengthen technical capability and enhance cooperation among relevant units. The study also emphasizes the importance of safety awareness in preventing incidents. These recommendations contribute to better protection of human life and the marine environment.
Keywords: oil rig, dismantling, decommissioning, Song Doc incident, fire safety and emergency response, safety management, industrial safety, oil and gas.
ДЕМОНТАЖ МОРСКИХ БУРОВЫХ УСТАНОВОК ПРОБЛЕМЫ ОБЕСПЕЧЕНИЯ ПОЖАРНОЙ БЕЗОПАСНОСТИ И ВЫВОДЫ ПО ИНЦИДЕНТУ НА ПЛОЩАДКЕ СОНГ ДОК
В данной работе рассматриваются основные проблемы в области пожарной безопасности и аварийно-спасательных мероприятий при выводе из эксплуатации морских нефтегазовых платформ на примере пожара на площадке Сонг Док, произошедшего 21 мая 2025 года. Выявлены характерные риски, связанные с остаточными опасными факторами, координацией работ и ограниченными возможностями контроля. Анализ указывает на недостатки в организации, надзоре и подготовке персонала. Предлагается комплекс мер по совершенствованию нормативной базы, укреплению технической готовности и повышению взаимодействия между ответственными структурами. Работа подчеркивает важность формирования культуры безопасности для предотвращения инцидентов. Эти рекомендации направлены на улучшение защиты человеческой жизни и морской среды.
Ключевые слова: морская буровая установка, демонтаж, вывод из эксплуатации, инцидент Сонг Док, пожарная безопасность и спасательные работы, управление безопасностью, промышленная безопасность, нефтегазовая отрасль.
1. Introduction
Offshore rig decommissioning is an increasingly important stage in the life cycle of oil and gas infrastructure as many aging platforms reach the end of their operational service. Although decommissioning activities aim to ensure the safe removal and environmental restoration of offshore structures, they also introduce complex fire and explosion risks. Residual hydrocarbons, structural deterioration and the gradual reduction of personnel and monitoring systems can significantly increase the likelihood and potential impact of fire incidents during late phase operations. These risks require careful management because conventional safety protocols designed for active production platforms may not fully address the unique conditions of decommissioning sites.
In recent years, several international regulatory bodies and industry organizations have recognized that fire safety during offshore decommissioning remains insufficiently standardized. Guidance is scattered across production oriented safety rules, general marine regulations and voluntary industry practices. As a result, operators and contractors often rely on internal procedures that may not adequately reflect the specific hazards associated with shut-in wells, gas pockets, corroded equipment or the removal of topside modules. Academic research on fire safety in decommissioning operations also remains limited compared to studies on drilling, production or transportation.
Against this backdrop, real world incidents play an important role in highlighting systemic weaknesses that may not yet be fully addressed in existing guidelines. The 2025 fire on the Song Doc platform provides a representative example of the challenges faced during offshore rig decommissioning in Southeast Asia. The incident revealed gaps in hazard assessment, contractor coordination and emergency preparedness, offering valuable insights for both practitioners and regulators [1].
The purpose of this study is to analyze the fire safety challenges associated with offshore rig decommissioning and to draw practical insights from the Song Doc incident. By examining technical, organizational and procedural factors, the paper aims to identify areas where current practices fall short and to propose measures that can contribute to safer and more sustainable decommissioning operations. The study also seeks to support ongoing discussions about the need for more specialized regulatory guidance tailored to the specific conditions of offshore decommissioning environments.
2. Technical and Organizational Challenges in Offshore Rig Decommissioning
Offshore rig decommissioning involves a transition from active production to a phased reduction of operational capacity, during which many of the engineered safety barriers of a functioning platform become weakened or unavailable. This transition introduces a set of technical and organizational challenges that make fire safety management significantly more complex than during the production phase. Understanding these challenges is essential for preventing incidents and maintaining safety integrity throughout the decommissioning process.
One major technical challenge is the presence of residual hydrocarbons in pipelines, storage systems and equipment that have not been fully inerted or flushed. Even small volumes of trapped gas can migrate into confined spaces or accumulate in areas with limited ventilation, creating ignition prone conditions. Aging equipment increases this risk. Corroded valves, brittle gaskets and deterioration of insulation materials undermine the reliability of mechanical barriers and can allow flammable substances to leak unexpectedly. As structural integrity declines, load bearing components become more vulnerable to heat damage, and fire progression can accelerate [2, 3].
Another concern is the reduction or shutdown of monitoring and detection systems. Fire and gas detection networks, automated shutdown systems and suppression mechanisms may be partially deactivated as equipment is removed or isolated. Limited instrumentation reduces situational awareness and increases dependence on manual detection by a shrinking workforce. The reduction of lighting, ventilation and auxiliary power also affects the crew’s ability to identify early warning signs, especially in areas undergoing dismantling.
Organizational challenges compound these technical risks. Decommissioning often involves multiple contractors responsible for different tasks such as heavy lifting, cutting, waste handling and well plugging. Coordination becomes difficult when teams follow different procedures or levels of safety training. Misalignment in risk communication can result in gaps in hazard identification or uncontrolled ignition sources during hot work or equipment removal. Because crews rotate frequently, knowledge transfer between shifts may be incomplete or inconsistent.
Changes in staffing levels also influence safety performance. As projects enter late stage decommissioning, the number of personnel on board typically decreases. While this reduces the potential for human exposure, it also limits emergency response capability. Smaller teams may struggle to manage large scale fire scenarios, especially when escape routes and muster areas are affected by ongoing dismantling activities.
Furthermore, regulatory and procedural frameworks for offshore decommissioning remain less developed than those for drilling or production. Many operators rely on customized internal procedures that vary widely in quality and scope. In regions where offshore decommissioning is relatively new, oversight mechanisms may not yet fully reflect the specific risks associated with residual hydrocarbons, structural degradation or the removal of critical safety systems. This regulatory gap contributes to inconsistencies in safety planning, risk assessment and emergency preparedness.
Taken together, these technical and organizational challenges highlight the need for enhanced fire safety measures in offshore rig decommissioning. A detailed analysis of real world incidents, such as the Song Doc event, can provide further insight into how these challenges emerge and how they can be addressed through more robust management practices.
3. Case Analysis of the Song Doc Incident
The 2025 fire on the Song Doc platform occurred during the late phase of decommissioning, when several production systems had already been shut down and structural dismantling was underway. Although the platform was no longer engaged in active extraction, significant residual hazards remained present in pipelines, wellheads and processing modules. The incident provides a representative example of how technical degradation, incomplete hazard assessment and organizational weaknesses can converge during offshore decommissioning.
Preliminary findings indicate that pockets of residual gas were trapped within sections of piping that had not been fully isolated or purged before dismantling activities commenced. As corrosion had weakened several valves and seals, traces of hydrocarbons gradually migrated toward areas where hot work was taking place. Ventilation in these zones was limited due to the partial removal of auxiliary equipment, allowing flammable gas to accumulate without detection. The fire was believed to have been triggered by a spark during metal cutting operations, although the exact ignition source could not be confirmed [4].
The incident also exposed gaps in monitoring and early detection capabilities. Several fire and gas sensors had been deactivated or removed as part of the decommissioning sequence, reducing the platform’s ability to identify abnormal conditions in real time. Manual detection by workers became the primary means of identifying hazards, yet reduced lighting and constrained access in dismantling areas made this task more difficult. By the time flames were observed, the fire had already spread to surrounding modules.
Organizational factors further contributed to the severity of the incident. Multiple contractors were present on the platform at the time of the fire, each responsible for separate tasks and following different internal safety procedures. Coordination between teams was limited, and there was no single unified oversight mechanism to ensure consistent hazard communication. As a result, not all groups were aware of the presence of residual hydrocarbons or the specific risks associated with ongoing hot work.
Emergency response efforts were also hindered by reduced staffing levels. With only a small crew remaining on board, the team’s ability to contain the fire before it escalated was limited. Some designated escape routes and muster points had been modified or obstructed due to dismantling work, complicating evacuation procedures. Although the fire was eventually controlled, the incident highlighted the vulnerability of offshore structures when emergency resources and operational systems are no longer fully available.
The Song Doc incident demonstrates how technical and organizational shortcomings can interact during decommissioning operations. Residual hydrocarbons, deteriorating equipment, reduced monitoring capacity and fragmented contractor coordination collectively created conditions conducive to a fire event. Lessons from this case underscore the need for targeted safety planning, specialized risk assessments and robust emergency preparedness tailored to the unique characteristics of offshore rig decommissioning.
4. Recommendations for Improving Fire Safety in Offshore Rig Decommissioning
Improving fire safety during offshore rig decommissioning requires a combination of technical, organizational and regulatory measures. Because the conditions of late phase operations differ markedly from those of active production, safety strategies must reflect the specific hazards associated with residual hydrocarbons, structural degradation and reduced staffing levels. The following recommendations aim to support operators, contractors and regulators in strengthening risk control throughout the decommissioning process.
A first priority is to enhance hazard identification and risk assessment procedures. Standard assessments designed for operating platforms may overlook conditions that are unique to dismantling activities, such as gas trapped in dead legs, corrosion induced leaks or weakened load bearing structures. Comprehensive surveys using gas detection tools, non destructive testing and structural assessment should be conducted before and during each major step of the decommissioning sequence. Residual gas must be purged or inerted systematically, and isolation procedures should be verified through independent checks.
A second recommendation concerns the restoration or temporary reinforcement of monitoring and detection capacity. Even if parts of the platform are offline, critical fire and gas sensors should remain functional until the final stages of dismantling. Where fixed systems are unavailable, portable detectors and continuous atmospheric monitoring should be used to ensure real time awareness. Improving lighting, ventilation and accessibility in dismantling zones also helps crews detect early warning signs and reduces the likelihood of undetected accumulation of flammable gases.
Third, coordination among the various contractors involved in decommissioning must be strengthened. A unified safety management structure should be established, supported by a single oversight authority responsible for approving work permits, communicating hazards and synchronizing hot work with isolation activities. Contractors should follow harmonized procedures instead of relying on separate internal rules. Regular briefings that involve all work groups are essential for preventing misunderstandings and ensuring that information about hazards is shared consistently.
Emergency preparedness also requires significant improvement. Decommissioning crews are typically smaller than those on active platforms, which limits the capacity to respond quickly to fire events. To compensate, operators should develop simplified emergency procedures tailored to reduced staffing levels and ensure that crews are trained in rapid response actions. Muster points, escape routes and fire suppression equipment should be adapted to account for changes in platform layout during dismantling. Drills should be conducted more frequently to reinforce readiness.
Finally, the development of dedicated regulatory guidance for offshore decommissioning is needed. Current safety regulations often focus on production operations and do not fully address the distinct hazards that arise during decommissioning [5]. National authorities and industry organizations should consider creating specialized safety standards that outline minimum requirements for hazard assessment, gas management, monitoring systems and emergency response during dismantling. Clearer guidelines can help operators align their procedures with best practices and reduce the variability that currently exists across projects.
Together, these recommendations highlight the need for a proactive, integrated and context specific approach to fire safety. Strengthening technical controls, improving coordination and establishing clearer regulatory expectations can significantly reduce the risk of incidents and contribute to safer and more sustainable offshore rig decommissioning.
5. Conclusion
Offshore rig decommissioning presents a distinct set of fire safety challenges that differ considerably from those encountered during active production. Residual hydrocarbons, degradation of structural and mechanical systems, reduced monitoring capacity and the involvement of multiple contractors create a complex risk environment that requires careful and continuous management. The Song Doc incident illustrates how these factors can converge during dismantling operations and how gaps in hazard assessment, detection capability and coordination can elevate the likelihood and severity of fire events.
The analysis of technical and organizational weaknesses observed in the incident highlights the need for enhanced safety planning that is tailored to the unique conditions of decommissioning. Strengthening hazard identification, improving monitoring systems, harmonizing contractor procedures and adapting emergency preparedness to reduced staffing levels are all essential steps for reducing risks. These measures must be supported by a more consistent regulatory framework that provides clearer guidance on safety requirements specific to decommissioning environments.
By integrating improved risk control practices with stronger organizational coordination, operators can significantly enhance the safety performance of offshore decommissioning projects. The lessons drawn from the Song Doc incident underscore the importance of proactive management and the value of developing specialized standards to support safer and more sustainable decommissioning activities.
References
1. Bureau of Safety and Environmental Enforcement (BSEE). (2015). Panel investigation report: Loss of well control and fire at the Hercules 265 Well A-3, South Timbalier Area Block 220 OCS-G 11564, July 23, 2013. U.S. Department of the Interior. Retrieved June 5, 2025, from https://www.bsee.gov/sites/bsee.gov/files/panel-investigation/incident-and-investigations/st-220-panel-report9-8-2015.pdf
2. American Petroleum Institute (API). (2014). Recommended practice 2SIM: Structural integrity management of fixed offshore structures (2nd ed., reaffirmed 2019). API Publishing Services, Washington, D.C.
3. Offshore Energies UK (OGUK). (2019). Guidelines on the management of ageing and life extension for UKCS oil and gas installations (Issue 1.1). Aberdeen: OGUK.
4. American Petroleum Institute (API). (2003). Recommended practice 2201: Safe hot tapping practices in the petroleum and petrochemical industries (5th ed., reaffirmed 2020). API Publishing Services, Washington, D.C.
5. National Offshore Petroleum Safety and Environmental Management Authority (NOPSEMA). (2023). Decommissioning of offshore petroleum infrastructure – Guideline and policy. Retrieved June 5, 2025, from https://www.nopsema.gov.au